Wednesday, 20 February 2013
Research: Ian Beesley
The Darkness
“Pictures of coal mining must inevitably fail in the attempt to portray the reality
of work underground – the impenetrable darkness, the noise of the machinery,
the soaking wet conditions, the heat and the dust”.
Albert Barlow BEM former Mayor of Wakefield and
NUM president of Caphouse colliery
Whilst there is a lot truth to this statement, the limitations of photography to
portray the reality of any situation are well known, because it is, as we know it,
a selective, silent non-tactile two-dimensional representation, but photography
has, and will continue to provide us with some of the most memorable and
important images that can interpret human activity.
It can create images that express emotion, atmosphere, and meaning, it can
record historic events, and bear witness to disease, conflict and atrocity and
celebrate the excitement and joy of life.
Photographs enable us to study and reflect upon those situations and events
that we may never have to confront in reality.
So whilst a photograph may fail to portray the reality or totality of any
situation) such as working working underground) it can at the very least
interpret some of the experience.
Mines and miners have always held a fascination for photographers. The
contrasts, harsh environment and closed underground world all appeal to the
photographerʼs eye. The representation of mines and miners has been
interpreted from both sides of the political and social spectrum, from the down
ward subversive gaze of the right, to the upward heroic gaze of the left
through to the commercial gaze of the mining companies.
It could be argued that the professional photographerʼs obsession with mines
and miners has in retrospect done little for the representation of an industry
and its community, but has managed to produce an aesthetic (or archive) that
has patronised, romanticized and sanitised the reality of mining
This unique environment has always presented a number of challenging
questions and many of the answers have become clichés in the
representation of mines and miners. Access to mines is problematic. There
are considerable dangers associated with photographing underground,
particularly the threat of explosion, triggered by the use of photographic
lighting.
These important issues of access with health and safety may explain why the
vast the majority of mining photography deals with the surface, in and around
the pithead, with miners coming or going on and off shift. The photographer is
on the outside looking in. Photography underground usually by official coal
board photographers (for illustrative and record purposes) is often very
brightly lit. Unnaturally we see every detail, every nut and bolt, every pit propsand support. The atmosphere has been obliterated in a single flash of
penetrating electronic light.
I decided I wanted to try and capture the atmosphere of working underground,
photographing the darkness, the claustrophobia, and the physicality of the
work. I was very lucky to achieve access to Hay Royds Colliery, particularly
as it is a gas free mine and there would be no restrictions on the use of
photographic equipment or lighting underground.
For me to express photographically the underground working world of the
miner presented a number of challenges, how to capture
The absolute and solid darkness which feels like it is saturated with the very
weight of the earth, pressing down and in on the mine and its miners. The
darting cap lamps that produce fleeting highlights, backlights, and sidelights
and dancing shadows.
The subdued colour palette created by the patina of coal dust that mutes
every colour turning vivid reds and oranges into rose and orange blushed
greys or blacks.
The insensitive introduction of the all seeing electronic flash with its
instantaneous blast of cruel light would destroy the very thing I was trying to
capture, the darkness.
My first attempts at photography underground (one August, twenty years ago)
I tried to use only the light from the miners cap lamps. Using a Leica M6 and
some up rated black and white film, the results were interesting though not
entirely satisfactory. The images captured the pools of light, within the
darkness but there seemed to be to no feeling of the claustrophobia nor sense
of danger and threat.
I began to search for images that held a sense of threat and claustrophobia.
This led me to consider cinemas film noire and I realized that the
cinematography used in Orson Welles “ A touch of evil” with its low
viewpoints, wide angles and harsh lighting throwing menacing shadows
against the walls and ceilings produced the exactly right balance of tension,
threat and claustrophobia I which I had been looking for.
I decided to experiment with these techniques, whilst realizing I may lose
some of the darkness, a sense of danger and claustrophobia could be
created.
Using an electronic flash unit with its head wrapped in a couple of layers of
white kitchen roll (to soften the harshness of the light) and attached to my
camera via a two metre long cable, I was able to position myself and the light
at very low viewpoints. This accentuated the physicality of the miners, the
lowness of the roof and the dark shadows, which were now cast on the walls
and roof helped create that sense of threat, I was looking for. Interestingly the request I heard the most from the miners was that
“These photographs will be in black and white wonʼt they.”
When I asked them why, the response was always because
“Black and white looks more real, and itʼs more like it feels to us than those
colour photos”.
A couple of the miners commented that the black and white images looked
like they were taken years ago in the 1940s or 1950s and it would be difficult
for people to believe that they were in fact taken in 2010.
So using the same lighting and positioning techniques I began to experiment
with colour, but even with the flash head wrapped in a couple of layers of
white kitchen roll the coal muted colours were shocked back to their
aggressive tones by the fierceness of the electronic flash. I eventually
overcame this by underexposing by at least one half of a stop.
It has without a doubt been the hardest project I have ever undertaken, I am
not so sure I have managed to capture the experience of working
underground but I think I may have come pretty close.
Ian Beesley
February 2011
(Very useful text for my current assignment! An interesting read!)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment